The Ultimate Guide to AI Research Assistants: Elicit vs. ScholarAI
If you are still using ChatGPT to find academic sources, stop immediately.
ChatGPT is a "generative" engine, meaning it is designed to create plausible-sounding text, not to retrieve facts. When you ask it for citations, it often hallucinates—creating "ghost papers" by real authors that don't actually exist.
Enter the era of AI Research Assistants.
These are specialized tools designed for "Grounded QA." They don't guess; they look up real papers, read them, and answer your questions based only on the text. The two heavyweights in this space for 2025 are
But which one should you use for your thesis or assignment? This guide breaks down the differences.
1. Elicit: The Literature Review Machine
Best for: Finding papers and synthesizing data across many sources.
The "Killer Feature": The Matrix View
When you ask Elicit a question (e.g., "What are the effects of mindfulness on student anxiety?"), it doesn't just write a paragraph. It finds the top 10-20 relevant papers and builds a table.
You can then add columns to this table for specific data points you want to extract, such as:
Number of participants
Methodology used
Limitations of the study
Main findings
Elicit scans the full text of these papers and fills in the cells for you. This turns a week of skimming abstracts into a 5-minute task.
When to use Elicit:
The Scoping Phase: When you are starting a new topic and need to know "what's out there."
Systematic Reviews: When you need to compare 50 papers on the exact same criteria (e.g., "Show me the dosage used in all these clinical trials").
Finding Gaps: You can sort papers by date or citation count to see where the research stops.
!
2. ScholarAI: The Deep Reader
Best for: Deep diving into full-text PDFs and finding specific facts.
While Elicit is about breadth (scanning many papers),
Originally a ChatGPT plugin, ScholarAI is now a standalone web app that connects directly to open-access repositories and publisher databases (like Springer and Taylor & Francis).
The "Killer Feature": The Copilot
ScholarAI excels at "reading" full text.
If you ask, "What statistical method did they use?", ScholarAI will answer and provide a clickable link that jumps you directly to the sentence in the PDF where the method is described.
When to use ScholarAI:
The Reading Phase: When you have found the 5 golden papers for your essay and need to understand them inside out.
Fact Checking: When you need to verify a specific claim or finding.
Math & Tables: ScholarAI is surprisingly good at reading data inside complex tables and figures, which other AI tools often ignore.
!’ that connects to highlighted text in the PDF.]
3. Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Elicit | ScholarAI |
| Primary Goal | Literature Review & Synthesis | Deep Reading & Retrieval |
| Best For | Comparing 50 papers at once | Interrogating 1 paper deeply |
| Output Format | Tables / Matrix | Chat / Copilot |
| Database | Semantic Scholar (200M+ papers) | PubMed, Arxiv, Springer, etc. |
| Full Text Access | Good (Open Access) | Excellent (Includes some paywalled) |
| Hallucination Risk | Very Low | Very Low |
4. Pricing: Which is Student Friendly?
Elicit Pricing:
Basic (Free): Very generous. Includes unlimited searches and summaries for your top 4 papers.
9 You get limited credits for "extracting data" into columns.Plus ($12/month): Necessary if you are doing a heavy thesis. Allows you to export your data to CSV (Excel) and extract data from hundreds of papers.
10
ScholarAI Pricing:
Free Plan: Gives you limited daily credits to ask questions. Good for casual use.
Personal ($9.99/month): Unlocks more "credits" for deep analysis. If you are in a STEM field dealing with dense PDFs, this is worth the investment during finals week.
The Verdict: The "Sandwich" Workflow
You shouldn't choose one; you should use them in a sequence. The best researchers in 2025 use the Elicit-ScholarAI Sandwich:
Start with Elicit: Use it to search for your topic. Use the Matrix view to filter through 100 papers and find the 5 most relevant ones.
Move to ScholarAI: Take those 5 papers and import them into ScholarAI. Use the Copilot to read them deeply, ask questions, and pull specific quotes.
Finish with Elicit: Go back to Elicit to generate a synthesis of how these papers contradict or support each other for your literature review section.
11
The Winner?
For Undergraduates writing standard essays: ScholarAI is easier to use.
For Postgrad/PhD students doing original research: Elicit is non-negotiable.